SERVER - Intel/AMD

[TOMVER]

Potřebuji poradit.
Budu stavět server a nevím jestli Intel nebo AMD. Poběží naněm Windows SBS 2003.

1)Intel:
Abit SC-1P + cpu P4 3.00E/800 box PRESCOTT HT 1MB cache + 1GBRAM + 200GB SATA Raid 0
Popis SC-1P
CPU
Supports Intel® Pentium 4 Northwood/Prescott Socket 478 processors with 800/533MHz FSB
New power design for Prescott CPU
Supports Intel® Hyper-Threading Technology

Chipset
Intel® E7210/6300ESB (Hance Rapids)
Supports Dual Channel DDR 400/333 with ECC function and Turbo mode
Supports Advanced Configuration and Power Management Interface (ACPI)

Memory
Four 184-pin DIMM sockets
Supports 144-bit wide Dual Channel DDR 400/333 memory
Up to 4GB, un-buffered with ECC/Non-ECC memory capacity

VGA
On board ATi Rage XL PCI interface VGA
Serial ATA

2 channel Serial ATA 150MB/s data transfer rate via Intel® 6300ESB
4 channel Serial ATA 150MB/s data transfer rate via Silicon Image 3114 (Optional)

System BIOS
Supports Plug-and-Play (PNP)
Supports Advanced Configuration Power Interface (ACPI)
Write-Protect Anti-Virus function by AWARD BIOS
4MB Flash ROM

LAN
Intel® 82545EM single port 64-bit Gigabit Ethernet controllers * 1
Intel® 82547GI single port Gigabit Ethernet controllers * 1
Front panel LAN Active/Link LED

Expansion Slot
PCI-X*2, 64bit/66MHz (3.3V)
PCI*3, 32bit/33MHz (5V)

Internal I/O connectors
1 Floppy port supports up to 2.88MB
2 Ultra DMA 100/66/33 connectors
1 COM port header (COM2)
6 Serial ATA 150 connectors
1 USB 2.0 header (Each header support two USB 2.0 devices)
1 SM Bus header (For SM Bus and I2C)

Back Panel I/O
PS/2 Keyboard and mouse ports
1 Printer port
1 COM port
1 Dual USB 2.0, 1 x RJ-45 LAN connector w/ transformer
1 RJ-45 w/ Transformer LAN connector

Miscellaneous
ATX form factor (305*243mm)
Hardware monitoring – Including Fan speeds, Voltages, System environment temperature
Chassis intrusion detector
3.3V/5V riser card supported (Optional)

2)AMD:
Abit SV-1A + cpu Athlon 64 3200+ box socket 939 + 1GBRAM + 200GB SATA Raid 0
Popis SV-1A
CPU
Supports Intel® Pentium 4 Northwood/Prescott Socket 478 processors with 800/533MHz FSB
New power design for Prescott CPU
Supports Intel® Hyper-Threading Technology

Chipset
Intel® E7210/6300ESB (Hance Rapids)
Supports Dual Channel DDR 400/333 with ECC function and Turbo mode
Supports Advanced Configuration and Power Management Interface (ACPI)

Memory
Four 184-pin DIMM sockets
Supports 144-bit wide Dual Channel DDR 400/333 memory
Up to 4GB, un-buffered with ECC/Non-ECC memory capacity

VGA
On board ATi Rage XL PCI interface VGA

Serial ATA
2 channel Serial ATA 150MB/s data transfer rate via Intel® 6300ESB
4 channel Serial ATA 150MB/s data transfer rate via Silicon Image 3114 (Optional)

System BIOS
Supports Plug-and-Play (PNP)
Supports Advanced Configuration Power Interface (ACPI)
Write-Protect Anti-Virus function by AWARD BIOS
4MB Flash ROM

LAN
Intel® 82545EM single port 64-bit Gigabit Ethernet controllers * 1
Intel® 82547GI single port Gigabit Ethernet controllers * 1
Front panel LAN Active/Link LED

Expansion Slot
PCI-X*2, 64bit/66MHz (3.3V)
PCI*3, 32bit/33MHz (5V)

Internal I/O connectors
1 Floppy port supports up to 2.88MB
2 Ultra DMA 100/66/33 connectors
1 COM port header (COM2)
6 Serial ATA 150 connectors
1 USB 2.0 header (Each header support two USB 2.0 devices)
1 SM Bus header (For SM Bus and I2C)

Back Panel I/O
PS/2 Keyboard and mouse ports
1 Printer port
1 COM port
1 Dual USB 2.0, 1 x RJ-45 LAN connector w/ transformer
1 RJ-45 w/ Transformer LAN connector

Miscellaneous
ATX form factor (305*243mm)
Hardware monitoring – Including Fan speeds, Voltages, System environment temperature
Chassis intrusion detector
3.3V/5V riser card supported (Optional)

[Fox!MURDER]

amd do intel desky nenarves ...
a kdyz intel server mobo tak snad jedine primo od Intelu...

[tosuja]

Bude to fileserver? Router/shaper/firewall? Nevyplati se hardwarovy radic, alespon kvuli bezpecnosti dat?

Serverove desky pro Intel - Tyan, Intel, Supermicro, mozna (ale radsi ne) Asus.
Pro AMD nevim, urcite Tyan.

Pokud to ma mit jeden procesor, tak je to jedno, pokud by jich bylo vice, rozhodne AMD. Dej si ale dobry pozor na pruchodnosti sbernic, tzn. at je tam dostatek kanalu (pozor, ne slotu?) PCI/PCI-X sbernic.